Thursday, November 7, 2019

Who smelt that?

Have you ever asked yourself what it would be like if you lose one of your senses? Or what would be your life experience if you were born without them? Though I’m sure most of us are thinking about sight or hearing right now, some people are born without sensations of smell. The condition is called congenital anosmia and is a lifelong inability to smell. For the most part, scientists ascribe the ability to smell to the olfactory bulbs in our brains, which are two small nerve endings that sit right between the nostrils and the brain. However, researchers have, by accident, discovered that some people define medical science.

When Israeli scientists conducted brain scans on people with normal ability to smell, they discovered a woman who had an abnormity in her brain. It was found during MRI scans that the subject had no olfactory bulbs in her brain, yet she was able to participate in experiments that required her to use her smell. For all that the scientists knew, that should have been impossible. Follow up tests were conducted with six hundred participants that would fit the attributes of the woman without the olfactory bulbs, and the scientist found two more women who could smell without the required brain structure.

With more test subjects, the scientists were able to create better comparison experiments, and they discovered that the women with the missing olfactory bulbs were not only able to smell, but their sense was also better than those with normally developed structures. All those findings disagree with the medial consensus that olfactory bulbs are responsible for transmitting smells to the brain. "Our understanding is that odors are essentially mapped on the surface of the bulbs," and the brain somehow reads this map, stated one of the scientist.  If you lack this map, you should also lack the ability to smell, he added. So how do these women do that?
One hypothesis here is that the brain has more plasticity, the ability to adapt and change through experiences, than initially fought. Even though the subjects were born without those important structures, their developing brains must have assigned the smelling task to some other parts. Another idea suggests that olfactory bulbs might not work as we fought they do. The researchers think that olfaction may be responsible for distinguishing where the smell comes from but no what it actually is. However, those speculations would need to be proven in further research.

Though we are left with unanswered questions, scientists were able to make additional observations that may help to design better research experiments in the future. All of the women with the peculiar ability were left-handed. The only reason why it was possible to find this medical mystery is that the original experiment did not exclude left-handed participants. Usually, those are left out because of different brain wirings compared to right-handed people.

- Posted by Gene (8)

9 comments:

  1. That is unbelievable , I wonder what these people smell when they think they are smelling . but I think it may be that lacking that structure enhanced something else in their brains that allows them to smell
    - Fredjah Desmezeaux

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is actually a great question. How would we know that they were able to smell the 'same' as a normal person? They may have the ability to distinguish between smells , but do lemons smell like lemons and flowers like flowers for them? Sometimes it's difficult to know what a person perceives. For example many people actually don't know they are colorblind for a long time, yet they manage to navigate well through life.
      -Gene

      Delete
  2. I wonder if this peculiar ability to smell without olfactory bulbs belongs only to women or only to people that are left handed. In either case, I believe the source of the ability must lie somewhere in the brain of the subjects. If the cause for this unique ability has to do with being female, I wonder what physiological differences might exist between the female and male brain that allows this. If the cause for smelling without olfactory bulbs has to do with being left-handed, the biological answer may lie in the division of activities each hemisphere of the brain has. If this is the case than the physiological mechanisms for smelling without olfactory bulbs could be found in the right hemisphere of the brain (because of the opposing control of the brain hemispheres).

    -David Frykenberg

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was thinking the same questions and my guess would be yes and no. I don't believe the sex has anything to do with this ability. The only reason they detected it in the three women is because the scientist used only women for the follow up studies. However, I think the fact that they all are left handed is very interesting and I wouldn't be surprised if it has something to do with the rewiring of the brain.
      -Gene

      Delete
  3. This is a very interesting post. I did not know much about the way we smell or the structures involved before this. But the fact that some people can smell without these olfactory bulbs is really interesting and amazing. It is very interesting that the only left handed people have this strange phenomenon. I wonder at what stage of development the brain develops a different way for the person to be able to smell.

    Posted by John Mariano

    ReplyDelete
  4. I found this post really interesting. If someone told me their olfactory bulb was not working then I'd assume that they wouldn't be able to smell. I was really surprised when you mentioned how not only were the women able to smell, but they had better sense than people who had an olfactory bulb. This makes me think, are there other senses that are brains are able make function? If people are missing certain requirements for senses, why can't our brain just adapt for those losses and fix it so that nobody has to miss out? I'm curious to see what further tests will be conducted from the results of this experiment. I think it will cause a lot more research into different senses as well as how they can vary with genders.

    -Matt Cayer

    ReplyDelete
  5. This post was super interesting to me. I didn't know that people without olfactory bulbs could still smell let alone could have a better sense of smell than some people who did. I know that sometimes people who lack one sense can make up for it in another. for example my friends mom has only partial hearing but her sense of smell is incredible. I am also curious if this none olfactory sense of smell is only in women or if it could happen in all people. This is a really curious case and I am definitely going to look more into it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. - above posted by Sophie DeRepentigny

      Delete
  6. My first thought was, "Duh, woman have brain capacities far beyond scientific explanation." But in all seriousness, I would like to know more about this phenomenon only occurring in woman. I agree that the brain is more plastic than previously thought. Specifically in the context of the mind-body connection. There is so much still to learn.

    Posted by Lauren Mason

    ReplyDelete